Need help submitting your writing to literary journals or book publishers/literary agents? Click here! →

Think Like A Doctor: Diagnose And Cure What Ails Your Book

One of the most important skills you can have as a writer is the ability to detach yourself from your work and diagnose its weaknesses objectively—as if you were a doctor examining a patient.

We all get married to a word, a turn of a phrase, a paragraph that is stylistically glorious. But what may showcase your prose style may also detract from your book’s plot (and vice versa). It takes the ability to look at your work in a clinical manner—with you as the cool, dispassionate, detached doctor whose only mission is to diagnose and cure the ills.

It is not easy—we all get emotionally involved with our work—but with practice you can become your own book’s best doctor. You diagnose the problems and you devise the cures. Sometimes only an aspirin will be needed; other times a scalpel will be required; and sometimes, unfortunately, only radical, risky surgery will save the patient.

What’s Up, Doc? How To Diagnose And Treat What Ails You (And Your Book)

Symptom 1: Your story starts out exciting, but then turns boring.

Diagnosis: You put on your white coat, step back, and analyze why. You deduce that there is too much “filler” instead of high-tension story. Your professional opinion: midsection prolapse or, more commonly, saggy-middle syndrome.

Cure: Add conflict. What is conflict? Quite simply, it is the interaction of two opposing forces. Conflict can take an infinite number of forms, such as character against character, or character against nature or other macro forces, or even opposing forces within a single character (“To be, or not to be, that is the question…”).

As a good doctor, it is your job to know what type of conflict will best suit your book: whether to introduce a series of small conflicts or one large conflict that runs the length of the story. Not only do conflict and conflict resolution make for more interesting reading, but they also fulfill the natural human urge to take sides—to root for the home team—thereby more fully engaging your reader.

When deciding how to introduce conflict, make sure to observe the Hippocratic oath and, above all, do no harm. Don’t overprescribe and introduce too much, or contextually inappropriate, conflict. And promise that you won’t morph from a skilled doctor into a quack by introducing easy-way-out conflict resolution devices like the deus ex machina!

Submit to Review Board

Symptom 2: Readers finish your book, but are left feeling empty; they just didn’t feel a lot of emotion.

Diagnosis: After considering all the options, you diagnose the problem as empathy reuptake inhibition, or in layman’s terms, anemic character syndrome. You determine that your characters are not empathetic; that they lack personality; that they are neither likable nor hateable. In a word, they are blah.

Cure: Doctor, give them an injection of steroids. Punch up your characterizations. Make your heroes more relatable and your villains more detestable. But also give your heroes flaws that make them human, and your villains attributes that make the reader, if not sympathetic with them, understanding of how they came to be the way they are. Read more: Characters We Love To Hate: How To Pull Off Unlikable Characters.

Transform every character not into a stereotype, but an archetype. That is, describe them so vividly and have them behave so consistently that a reader will know who you are talking about, even when the name isn’t given. And by drawing the characters so clearly, when they say or do something out of character, it makes it all the more impactful.

Cultivating the ability to analyze your work clinically, as a doctor would an ailing patient, will pay huge dividends. It often means swallowing one’s pride, but the end product makes it all worthwhile!

Writer QuestionsQUESTION: How good are you at dispassionately critiquing your own work, diagnosing its flaws, and then curing them? Do you often take a scapel to your work?

6 Responses to Think Like A Doctor: Diagnose And Cure What Ails Your Book

  1. Very nice post. I especially like the steroid injection part ofcourse as a metaphor – live characters are always more engaging.

  2. David, we’re glad you enjoyed the post! And we definitely agree; writers often become emotionally invested in their own work, and taking a small break before revising/editing it is a great way to distance yourself and gain a more professional mind-set.

    And the pun is absolutely not excused! ;)

  3. A really good post, thanks; the doctor/patient analogy really works, cheers for that. :-) I’ll certainly be putting that into practice…. if you excuse the pun ;-)

    The other aspect to consider (which I’m certain you agree with and must of recommended elsewhere) is to leave your drafts alone in that proverbial bottom drawer for at least two weeks, preferably for a month or more; that way when you read it again it’s with a more objective eye; the “word-blindness” through familiarity is greatly lessened.

    “Greatly lessened”… didn’t quite cut it in the Annual International Oxymoron Contest…. ;-)

  4. Saggy-middle syndrom actually sounds like an actual health problem…

    But seriously though, it’s tough to try and work out your own issues. The key, I’ve found, is to be open to the opinion of others, kind of like a think tank—after all, they’re most likely readers themselves!

  5. I’m not very good at critiquing my own work at all. I fall victim to loving the first words I put on a page. My sister, however, is fabulous at critiquing my work; she’s like my in-home doctor of writing! :)

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign me up for
FREE Publishing Leads & Tips
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

WHY? Because our insider
know-how has helped
writers get over 18,000+ acceptances.

FREE Publishing Leads and Tips! Our e-publication, Submit Write Now!, delivered weekly to your inbox.
  • BEST (and proven) submission tips
  • Hot publishing leads
  • Calls to submit
  • Contest alerts
  • Notification of industry changes
  • And much more!
Live Chat Software