Need help submitting your writing to literary journals or book publishers/literary agents? Click here! →

The Importance of Critique for Serious and Successful Writers

Whether you are working on the first draft of your book, editing your short story, or experimenting with different forms of poetry, getting criticism from fellow writers (and readers) should be a regular part of your creative process. Let’s face it: anyone can put words on a page and call it a story, or divide those words up into stanzas and call it a poem. But successful authors know that constructive feedback from a freelance fiction editor, critique partner, or writers group is tantamount to perfecting the craft of writing.

There are many tools that writers who are serious about their craft can use to hone their skills. After struggling with the first draft of a piece, it is best to let it percolate for a while and come back to the page with a fresh eye. No one ever writes “The Road Not Taken” in one sitting. Once a writer has a piece he/she is fairly satisfied with, it’s time to send it out into the world for another opinion. Other eyes may see what you have missed, offer a different perspective, and question what you have taken for granted.

It is important that a writer does not exist in a vacuum. There are many quality writing workshops, continuing education courses, informal writing groups, and low-residency MFA programs that afford writers trustworthy outlets for critique.

While you may be tempted to have your mother, your significant other, or best friend read your work, they should not be your only editors. They are not trained to critique, may not understand your work, and may try to preserve your feelings, regardless of their true opinion.

Once you have received feedback from a source you trust, it’s back to revising again. Keep in mind you do not have to incorporate all suggestions that have been made. In fact, some writers revise TOO much. Look for the criticism you’ve received numerous times before changing the voice of your entire novel because one agent decided he or she might like it better if written in third person.

The object of critique is to force the writer to take an objective look at what has been written, evaluate its suitability, tighten the piece where needed, then let your words stand on their own. For more information about editing and critique, read How To Choose A Critique Partner For Your Writing, How To Choose A Freelance Editor For Your Writing, or Writers Groups.

4 Responses to The Importance of Critique for Serious and Successful Writers

  1. As an administrator for a newly created forum for poetry critique I have to thank you for advocating the benefits of critique. I feel like too many forums and writing groups, while well-intentioned, end up giving some writers an inflated sense of the quality of their work which leads them to stagnate.

    I have found that the process of giving critique can be as valuable as receiving it, and has helped me to improve my work simply by being more engaged and attentive to the nuances of poetry.

    I have shared the link to this article on the Forage Poetry Forum as I feel like it echoes everything we believe there.

  2. Yes, yes, yes! All the books I read and exercises I tried served no purpose compared to the power of quality critique from fellow writers dedicated to making each other better at the craft. That group is the reason I’ve finished projects and published my work.

  3. "The object of critique is to force the writer to take an objective look at what has been written, evaluate its suitability, tighten the piece where needed, then let your words stand on their own." Would make a great plaque; thank you.

Leave a reply

Live Chat Software


This page was chock-full of great info...
and there's so much more here to help you meet your publishing goals!

Be sure to sign up for our FREE guides as you enter each site.

For advice, marketing ideas, and step-by-step guidance through the self-publishing process!

Featuring smart ways to boost your online presence, build your author website, or improve your existing website.

For everything you need to know about writing, preparing, and targeting submissions to literary agents and editors!

Free Publishing Leads and Tips

Our e-publication, Submit Write Now!, will be delivered weekly to your inbox.

Join the 50,000+ writers who receive:

  • FREE submission tips
  • Hot publishing leads
  • Calls to submit
  • And much more!

Close this popup

Sign up Today!

BONUS: Receive a free copy of formatting guidelines—our gift to you!

We promise not to share your information.